Backstreet Boys Frontman Nick Carter Dismisses Sexual Assault Allegations; Attorney Calls Claims ‘Outrageous’

Nick Carter’s attorney reiterated his client’s innocence after the release of

Fallen Idols: Aaron and Nick Carter. The docuseries features interviews with the three women accusing Carter of sexual assault.

Trigger Warning

This article contains references to sexual assault, alcohol and drug addiction, and deaths.

Nick Carter has firmly stood his ground and pleaded innocence following the release of Investigation Discovery’s Fallen Idols: Aaron and Nick Carter, which aired on Monday, May 27, and Tuesday, May 28, respectively. The four-part documentary series features interviews with former Dream pop group members Melissa Schuman, Shannon Ruth, and Ashley Repp. The three women have filed individual sexual assault lawsuits against the Backstreet Boys frontman.

“These are exactly the same outrageous claims that led us to sue this gang of conspirators,” Carter’s attorney, Dale Hayes Jr., told The Hollywood Reporter on his client’s behalf. “Those cases are working their way through the legal system now, and, based on both the initial court rulings and the overwhelming evidence, we have every belief that we will prevail and hold them accountable for spreading falsehoods,” he added. Carter’s lawyer called the claims “not only legally meritless but also entirely untrue” at the time. Singer and former member of the girl group Dream, Melissa Schuman, per the aforementioned publication, claims Carter sexually assaulted her in 2002.

Detailed Report of the Cases Against Nick Carter

Shannon Ruth’s Allegations

Shannon Ruth filed a lawsuit against Nick Carter in December 2022, accusing the singer of sexually assaulting her when she was 17. Ruth, per Forbes, notes that Carter allegedly chose her out of a line of fans seeking his autograph in 2001. According to Ruth, the assault occurred on Carter’s tour bus, where he allegedly gave her alcohol and forced her to perform sexual acts. Carter’s lawyer called the claims “not only legally meritless but also entirely untrue” at the time.

Melissa Schuman’s Allegations

Singer and former member of the girl group Dream, Melissa Schuman, per the aforementioned publication, claims Nick Carter sexually assaulted her in 2002. Schuman, who was 18 at the time, alleges that Carter invited her to his apartment where the assault occurred. She reportedly publicly accused him of the same in 2018 before suing him in 2023. Schuman detailed her allegations in a blog post, stating that Carter overpowered her despite her repeated refusals.

Ashley Repp’s Allegations

Ashley Repp sued Nick Carter in August 2023, alleging he sexually assaulted her multiple times in 2003 when she was 15 and he was 23. Repp claimed Carter and she had known each other as family friends. She accused the singer of giving her alcohol and infecting her with HPV. Repp’s allegations include multiple instances of sexual assault, with the most severe taking place at a family gathering.

Nick Carter’s Defense

Nick Carter denies all the claims made by the three women. His attorney, Dale Hayes Jr., has consistently dismissed the allegations as fabrications aimed at damaging Carter’s reputation. In his statement to The Hollywood Reporter, Hayes emphasized the lack of credible evidence supporting the claims and highlighted the efforts to counter-sue the accusers for defamation. According to Carter’s legal team, these accusations are part of a coordinated attempt to extort money from the singer.

Impact of the Allegations on Nick Carter’s Career

The sexual assault allegations have undoubtedly affected Nick Carter’s career and public image. The Backstreet Boys, a globally recognized boy band, have had to navigate the fallout from these serious accusations. Concert cancellations, loss of endorsements, and strained relationships with fans are some of the repercussions Carter has faced. Despite this, Carter remains steadfast in his defense, seeking to clear his name and continue his career.

Public Reaction and Media Coverage

The public reaction to the allegations against Nick Carter has been polarized. While some fans and supporters believe in Carter’s innocence and view the accusations as baseless attacks, others have expressed their disappointment and support for the accusers. Media coverage of the case has been extensive, with various outlets providing in-depth analyses and updates on the legal proceedings. The release of Fallen Idols: Aaron and Nick Carter has further amplified the public discourse, bringing renewed attention to the allegations.

Legal Proceedings and Future Implications

As the legal proceedings continue, the future implications for Nick Carter remain uncertain. If found guilty, Carter could face severe legal consequences, including potential jail time and financial restitution to the accusers. Conversely, if Carter is exonerated, he and his legal team plan to pursue defamation lawsuits against the accusers. The outcome of these cases will significantly impact not only Carter’s personal and professional life but also the broader conversation around sexual assault allegations in the entertainment industry.


The allegations against Nick Carter highlight the complexities and challenges of navigating sexual assault accusations in the public eye. As the legal process unfolds, it is crucial to approach the situation with sensitivity and an understanding of the gravity of the claims. Nick Carter’s steadfast denial of the allegations and the ongoing legal battles underscore the importance of due process and the pursuit of justice for all parties involved.

Leave a Comment